The backroom politics around defining “sustainable” finance in Canada continue, with the vast majority of people shut out of this critical public policy issue. You may remember earlier chapters of this saga as the CSA Group convened industry and finance stakeholders behind closed doors to try to define a “transition” taxonomy for Canada but failed…

Today Scotiabank released its Net-Zero Pathways Report outlining its next steps regarding its net zero commitment. Reaction quote: “There’s nothing in these plans that will see Scotiabank reduce the tens of billions it pours into fossil fuels each year. In fact, by relying on intensity targets, the bank is allowing itself to expand this funding,…

Today the Toronto Dominion Bank (TD) released its next steps on its climate plan as part of its Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) reporting. Summary quote: “Unfortunately, TD has left the door firmly open to financing fossil fuel expansion by setting only weak intensity-based 2030 targets for energy and power generation. It’s unclear…

Today the Bank of Montreal (BMO) released the next steps of its climate commitments, a week after RBC. Here is our reaction, with some high-level highlights: "BMO moved to the head of the pack of big Canadian banks with their commitment to reduce financed emissions in the oil and gas sector in absolute and not…

It’s almost enough to make you think the bank doesn’t take shareholder opinion seriously. Rather than issue a specific defense of how its “sustainable investment” practices allow it to fund fossil fuel expansion and projects opposed by Indigenous peoples, RBC instead answered (p. 96 here) the resolution we filed with vague generalities and platitudes, leaving…

Today the Royal Bank of Canada (RBC) released the next steps of its climate plans as part of its Task Force on Climate-related Disclosures (TCFD) 2021 report. While there are some positive steps, overall RBC is falling behind in its efforts by failing to set 2030 targets for carbon-intensive sectors and by omitting the majority…

When is sustainable finance not sustainable finance? This sounds like a nerdy and unfunny joke, but let’s give the punchline anyway: When it’s given to companies increasing emissions during the climate crisis. That’s the crux of a shareholder resolution we filed with RBC this year that will go to a vote at its April 7…

Today the German group Urgewald released a bombshell of a report on coal financing, showing that banks provided loans and underwriting of US$1.5 trillion to companies on the Global Coal Exit List over the last two years, while institutional bondholders and shareholders held US$1.2 trillion as of November 2021. The report is shocking, demonstrating that…

Over the past few months, we’ve engaged each of the five largest Canadian banks on their climate work. We’ve filed a few shareholder proposals, at least one of which will be going to a vote (more on that soon). And we produced this best practices report which we will use to benchmark the banks after…

Word on the street is that the CSA Group’s transition taxonomy process has stalled out due to lack of consensus. (For background, see our earlier blog). This is just as well, since it was tracking towards a shockingly weak product that would have provoked surprise and probably a bit of outrage in ESG circles in…